A Practical Comparison of Light Sources

Light Source
Operation
Type of Light
Strengths
Weaknesses
Comments
Fluorescent
When electricity passes through mercury vapor in a glass tube the invisible light given off interacts with the coating in the glass and produces visible light All types of white light (e.g., warm white, cool white, daylight) with good to very good color rendition Gives off a lot of light and is energy-efficient. Newer, compact models can fit some residential fixtures Older fluorescents can make you look gray-green; many fluorescent fixtures cannot be dimmed New fluorescents with new coatings give fluorescent lights a much more flattering glow
           
Halogen
Similar to incandescent except that a small amount of a halogen gas is added to the glass envelope Crisp white light with very good color rendition Good for illuminating art and fitting into small areas. Need to be changed less often than incandescent bulbs; can be dimmed; better beam control allows light to be carefully focused The light can be too bright for living rooms or some decorative fixtures; light bulbs and fixtures can become very hot; touching glass will shorten the life of the light bulb Becoming increasing popular because of their ability to light well
           
Incandescent
When electricity passes through a metal filament to the point of “incandescence” the filament gives off light as well as plenty of heat Yellowish light with good color rendition Emits a warm light that flatters pretty much all skin tones; inexpensive to purchase; easily dimmable Cheaper models burn out quickly; use a lot more energy than fluorescents or halogens; emit a lot of heat The “daylight” varieties are closer to outdoor light than typical incandescent light bulbs
           
LED
When electricity passes through this electronic component it gives off light and becomes a Light Emitting Diode Many colors are available including warm white and cool white Uses very little energy or space; is inexpensive to operate; gives off with very little heat; can last for years Are not yet widely available for home use and certain types of fixtures can be expensive to purchase; cannot be dimmed Quickly becoming a standard in car dashboards, traffic lights, and taillights; home LEDs often require extra parts to operate
           
Xenon
Very similar to incandescent except a small amount of xenon gas is added to the glass envelope Similar to incandescent light only slightly less yellow Lasts longer than standard incandescents; can be dimmed; glass can be touched without reducing the life of the light bulb Not very energy-efficient; emit some heat but not as hot as halogen Becoming very popular for under cabinet lighting
           
Candle
Cloth wick surrounded by wax has a small burning flame that often “flickers” Very yellowish light Flame flicker makes everyone look their best and cannot be duplicated by electric light sources Fire hazard. Candles need to be replaced often to avoid messy half-burned look Almost everyone looks better in candlelight